-fA- vs [BH] issue .

[.vooDoo.]

duck and dodge, duck and dodge.  lol, to funny.  

[c| PsyOps]

HAHAHAHAHA!

Who could ever doubt the motives of Stripes?

[Stripes]

lol ? psy ?

[~Po~ TiroFino]

Noto, you're mistaken the interpretation of the Ghost Recon Ladder Rules:


[BH] does not have to send in a replay.? The world is full of choices, and if they choose not to send in the replay, then they will be on the receiving end of 1.0 Warning Point.? As far as I'm concerned, they have until 00.00 GMT 5/13/04 to produce a replay.? Otherwise, they will receive 1.0 Warning Point.


Rule 14 says:

"14. If one clan asks for a replay, the replays must be sent within 15 minutes after the CB was finished. If the replay is not sent within the 15 minute time frame given and won't be sent later(up to one hour later see warning points/penalties rules) the game of the missing replay will be changed to the good for the other clan. If two replays are missing it will be counted as you would have glitched twice. Notice that on dedicated servers you cannot save the replays. Therefore, as a consequence you cannot ask for replays on dedicated server."

So you see, they can choose not to send the replay, but in that case, the punishment will be the loss of that particular game - not just the warning points as you had incorrectly pointed out.....

the game of the missing replay will be changed to the good for the other clan.

So my input to this thread, since you wondered what it was, is only to see that the rule is enforced correctly - since I had a similar incident which didn't report because we ended up winning the CB. --- Thank You!  <By the way... I hate to revive old threads, but the mistake signaled above was huge and could not be oversighted>

[Stripes]

and i never got that freaking replay yet, but screw it we won anyway...

[Civrock]

warning points have been given.

[Noto]

Noto, you're mistaken the interpretation of the Ghost Recon Ladder Rules:

the game of the missing replay will be changed to the good for the other clan.

I thought -fA- had won that particular game anyway, which is why I was not concerned about changing it "to the good" for the other clan.  I know exactly what you are saying though.  I was simply addressing the actual replay issue itself, not the result of the game.

and i never got that freaking replay yet, but screw it we won anyway...

After finishing conversations with different folks, the [BH] has still not send in the replay asked for by the -fA- clan.  Since -fA- had won the CB anyway, no scoring will be changed and the result of the match will stay the same.  As for the [BH] clan, they have been given 1.0 warning point for not sending a replay at all according to the warning point system of the *DAMN Battle League Rules and also Rule 14.

I consider the matter closed.

Moderators:  Please lock this thread, and then post 1.0 warning point for the [BH] for this particular match.  Thank you.

.::|N| Noto